Taco Tires

Best Winter Tires for a Tacoma and Other Midsize Pickups

Tire types15 min readUpdated

By the Taco Tires editor

Short answer

For snow on plowed roads, a 3PMSF all-terrain is enough for a Tacoma or any midsize pickup. Our top snow score, 9/10, goes to the BFGoodrich All-Terrain T/A KO3, Falken Wildpeak A/T4W, Toyo Open Country A/T III, Yokohama Geolandar A/T4, and Goodyear Wrangler DuraTrac RT. Dedicated winter tires still win on regular ice or unplowed roads.

What are the best winter tires for a Tacoma?

Among the 50 year-round tires in our Tacoma research set, 27 carry the three-peak mountain snowflake (3PMSF) across their whole line, and they are the ones worth shortlisting for a truck that sees snow. The table ranks all of them by snow score. The top mark of 9/10 is shared by 5 models; among those, the BFGoodrich All-Terrain T/A KO3 has the best wet score (8/10), which matters because most winter miles are on cold, wet pavement rather than fresh powder.

#TireCategorySnowWetMarkingOverall rank
1BFGoodrich All-Terrain T/A KO3All-Terrain983PMSF2 of 50
2Falken Wildpeak A/T4WAll-Terrain983PMSF3 of 50
3Toyo Open Country A/T IIIAll-Terrain983PMSF4 of 50
4Yokohama Geolandar A/T4All-Terrain983PMSF7 of 50
5Goodyear Wrangler DuraTrac RTRugged-Terrain973PMSF13 of 50
6Continental TerrainContact A/T2All-Terrain893PMSF35 of 50
7Firestone Destination A/T2Mild All-Terrain883PMSF8 of 50
8Cooper Discoverer Road+Trail ATMild All-Terrain883PMSF10 of 50
9Cooper Discoverer AT3 4S/LTAll-Terrain883PMSF11 of 50
10Goodyear Wrangler Workhorse AT/AT2All-Terrain883PMSF14 of 50
11Hankook Dynapro AT2 XtremeAll-Terrain883PMSF17 of 50
12Pirelli Scorpion All Terrain PlusAll-Terrain883PMSF19 of 50
13Nitto Terra Grappler G3All-Terrain883PMSF20 of 50
14BFGoodrich Trail-Terrain T/AMild All-Terrain883PMSF26 of 50
15Sumitomo Encounter AT2All-Terrain883PMSF43 of 50
16Falken Rubitrek A/TAll-Terrain883PMSF44 of 50
17Yokohama Geolandar A/T G015Mild All-Terrain883PMSF45 of 50
18General Grabber APTMild All-Terrain883PMSF46 of 50
19BFGoodrich All-Terrain T/A KO2All-Terrain873PMSF6 of 50
20General Grabber A/TXAll-Terrain873PMSF12 of 50
21Kumho Road Venture AT52All-Terrain873PMSF16 of 50
22Toyo Open Country R/T TrailRugged-Terrain873PMSF22 of 50
23Falken Wildpeak R/T01Rugged-Terrain873PMSF23 of 50
24Mickey Thompson Baja Boss A/TRugged-Terrain873PMSF25 of 50
25Cooper Discoverer Rugged TrekRugged-Terrain873PMSF40 of 50
26Firestone Destination X/TRugged-Terrain873PMSF41 of 50
27Maxxis RAZR ATAll-Terrain873PMSF42 of 50
Every full-line 3PMSF tire in the 50-tire Tacoma research set, ordered by snow score, then wet score, then overall rank. Scores are a 0-10 editorial synthesis of published reviews, manufacturer specifications, and retailer fitment data — not tires we tested ourselves.

The marking and the score line up in this set. Full-line 3PMSF tires score 8-9 on snow; tires that carry only M+S score 2-6. That gap is the categories separating, not a coincidence: 16 of the 18 all-terrains are 3PMSF and their median snow score is 8, while the 9 mud-terrains have a median of 3.

What does our snow score measure, and what does it leave out?

The snow score is one of 10 axes each tire is rated on, from 0 to 10. It is an editorial synthesis of published reviews, manufacturer specifications, and retailer fitment data. Nobody here mounted these tires and drove them through a winter, and no lab test sits behind the number. Read it as a relative ranking: where a tire falls among these 50 models, not a measured traction figure.

  • It covers snow traction as the sources describe it: how well the tread bites and clears on snow-covered roads compared with the rest of the set.
  • It does not cover ice. The dataset has separate snow and wet axes but no ice axis, and the 3PMSF test is a snow test too.
  • It does not include dedicated winter tires. The set's categories run from highway / all-season to mud-terrain, so a 9 means best of the year-round tires, not best possible winter grip.
  • It rates the model, not one size. A snow marking can change from size to size, as it does on the Mickey Thompson Baja Boss M/T, so check the sidewall of the exact size you buy.
  • It says nothing about load range, tread depth, or how a particular set has worn.

How do tire categories compare in snow on a midsize pickup?

Category predicts winter behavior on a truck better than brand does. The all-terrains and their milder and more rugged cousins cluster high and mostly carry 3PMSF; highway all-seasons sit mid-pack on M+S alone; mud-terrains fill the bottom of the snow column.

CategoryTires in setSnow score rangeMedian snow scoreCarry 3PMSF
Highway / All-Season45-650
Mild All-Terrain85-885
All-Terrain184-9816
Rugged-Terrain114-986
Mud-Terrain92-630
Snow score by category across the same 50-tire set. The 3PMSF column counts full-line ratings only; the Mickey Thompson Baja Boss M/T is 3PMSF in select sizes and is not counted.

Mud-terrains are the wrong tool for winter

The 9 mud-terrains in our set score 2-6 on snow with a median of 3, and only the Mickey Thompson Baja Boss M/T carries 3PMSF, in select sizes only. Their big voids pack with snow instead of throwing it out, and the stiff blocks have little siping for ice. If you want an aggressive look that still works in winter, the Goodyear Wrangler DuraTrac RT is the rugged-terrain that shares the top snow score.

What is the difference between 3PMSF and M+S?

The two sidewall marks look like steps on one scale, and they are not. M+S (mud and snow, also written M/S or M&S) describes tread geometry: enough open void and the right block layout. The manufacturer applies it, and no traction test is involved, which is why nearly every light-truck all-season and all-terrain wears it, including tires that are poor in snow.

The three-peak mountain snowflake has to be earned. A tire carrying it passed a standardized acceleration test on medium-packed snow against a reference tire. That makes it the mark worth shopping on. It is still not an ice rating: the test does not measure braking, cornering, or glare ice, so a 3PMSF all-terrain and a studless winter tire can wear the same symbol and behave very differently on a polished on-ramp.

Read the sidewall, not the marketing

In our set, 27 of the 50 tires carry 3PMSF, 22 carry only M+S, and 1 is 3PMSF in some sizes and not others. M+S alone tells you nothing about winter grip.

Is a 3PMSF all-terrain good enough, or do you need dedicated snow tires?

Ice decides it more than snow does. A good 3PMSF all-terrain handles snow-covered, plowed roads well and still works in July, which is the case for it: one set, no swap, no second wheels to store. A dedicated winter tire runs a compound that stays soft in the cold and far denser siping that bites glare ice. Those advantages are invisible on a dry summer highway and decisive on a polished road near freezing.

Your winterBetter pickWhy
Plowed roads, a handful of storms a season3PMSF all-terrainPasses the snow-traction test and saves a second set of wheels
Mostly cold and dry, the odd snow day3PMSF all-terrainA winter compound wears faster on warm, dry pavement
Regular ice, freezing rain, or packed-snow commutesDedicated winter tireCold-pliable compound and dense siping grip ice; 3PMSF does not test ice
Unplowed roads or steep grades in sustained coldDedicated winter tireStopping and turning on packed snow need more than an all-terrain gives
A mud-terrain on the truck nowAdd a winter setMud-terrains have a median snow score of 3 in our set
Matching the tire to the winter you actually drive in. Our dataset has no dedicated winter tires, so this table rests on what each marking tests for, not on our scores.
  • A second set on its own wheels makes the seasonal swap a driveway job and keeps your good wheels out of the salt. Plan for TPMS sensors or a relearn on the winter set.
  • Studded tires go further on ice and are regulated by state and province, including the dates they are allowed. Check local rules before buying.
  • Four-wheel drive helps a truck get moving. It does nothing for stopping or turning, and those two jobs fall entirely on the tires.

What size should a winter tire set be for your Tacoma?

Start from the factory size, then check what the snow field looks like in it. The table counts the full-line 3PMSF models our dataset lists in each factory size, generation by generation. The 1st gen (1995-2004) is left out because the research set covers 2005-and-later trucks.

GenerationFactory sizeNominal size3PMSF models in our setBest snow score in that size
2nd gen (2005-2015)215/70R158.5 in wide, 26.9 in tallNone listed-
2nd gen (2005-2015)245/75R169.6 in wide, 30.5 in tall128
2nd gen (2005-2015)265/70R1610.4 in wide, 30.6 in tall118
2nd gen (2005-2015)265/65R1710.4 in wide, 30.6 in tall108
2nd gen (2005-2015)265/60R1810.4 in wide, 30.5 in tallNone listed-
2nd gen (2005-2015)255/45R1810.0 in wide, 27.0 in tallNone listed-
3rd gen (2016-2023)245/75R169.6 in wide, 30.5 in tall128
3rd gen (2016-2023)265/70R1610.4 in wide, 30.6 in tall118
3rd gen (2016-2023)265/65R1710.4 in wide, 30.6 in tall108
3rd gen (2016-2023)265/60R1810.4 in wide, 30.5 in tallNone listed-
4th gen (2024-2026)245/70R179.6 in wide, 30.5 in tall108
4th gen (2024-2026)265/70R1710.4 in wide, 31.6 in tall279
4th gen (2024-2026)265/65R1810.4 in wide, 31.6 in tall98
4th gen (2024-2026)265/70R1810.4 in wide, 32.6 in tall269
Full-line 3PMSF models listed in each factory Tacoma size, and the highest snow score among them. Availability is the dataset's record of the sizes each model is offered in. 2nd gen (2005-2015) sizes: long-running community-documented pattern, not a verified per-year spec. Confirm the exact size on the driver's door placard or the tire sidewall before you buy.

The size you already run decides more than you might expect. Among factory sizes, the dataset lists the 9/10 tier only in 265/70R17 and 265/70R18, which are 4th gen sizes. A 2nd gen or 3rd gen truck that stays on its factory size tops out at 8/10 in our set - still 3PMSF, still a capable winter all-terrain, just not the top tier. 215/70R15, 265/60R18, and 255/45R18 have no full-line 3PMSF model in the set at all.

18-inch factory size17-inch winter sizeDiameter change3PMSF models: 18-in vs 17-inBest snow score on 17sFactory 17-in size on the same generation?
265/60R18 (2nd gen and 3rd gen)265/65R17+0.04 inNone listed vs 108Yes, on other trims
255/45R18 (2nd gen)255/50R17+0.00 inNone listed vs Not in our size catalog-No
265/65R18 (4th gen)265/70R17+0.04 in9 vs 279Yes, on other trims
265/70R18 (4th gen)265/75R17+0.04 in26 vs Not in our size catalog-No
Each 18-inch factory size solved down to a 17-inch wheel at the same section width and nearly the same overall diameter. Diameter change is nominal, from the size codes.

A winter set is the one time a smaller wheel earns its place on a truck: a taller sidewall at the same overall height, and often a deeper winter catalog. Dropping 265/60R18 to 265/65R17 and 265/65R18 to 265/70R17 widens the 3PMSF field in our set. Our size catalog does not track 255/50R17 and 265/75R17, so this table cannot say whether those 17-inch sizes would help or hurt.

A smaller wheel has to clear the brakes

Nothing in our data records brake-caliper clearance for any Tacoma trim, and a 17-inch size being factory on another trim of the same generation does not prove it clears yours, since brake packages can differ. Before buying a smaller winter wheel, confirm caliper clearance with the wheel seller, and match the bolt pattern, hub bore, offset, and lug seat.

Does a narrower tire actually help a truck in snow?

Yes, for a geometric reason. A truck's weight is fixed. Spread it across a wider contact patch and the pressure on each square inch falls, so the tire tends to ride up on loose snow. Put the same weight on a narrower patch and the tire cuts down toward the firmer surface underneath, where the grip is, with less snow to push aside on the way.

On a 17-inch wheel the spread is real: a 245/70R17 is 9.6 in of nominal section width, a 265/70R17 is 10.4 in, and a 285/70R17 is 11.2 in. Going from the 285 to the 245 gives up 1.6 in of width at the same truck weight. If you want height without width, the 255/80R17 is 10.0 in wide at 33.1 in tall, and all 5 of the 9/10 snow models list it.

The narrowest class, 245/75R16 and 245/70R17, is served by the milder end of the 3PMSF field: 12 models list one of the two, and the best snow score among them is 8. Fit is the other catch - going narrower or taller than stock moves the speedometer and effective gearing, so run the change through the tire calculator before ordering.

How does cold weather change your tire pressure?

Cool a sealed tire and its pressure drops. Our pressure calculator uses about 2 percent per 10 degrees Fahrenheit, which is 0.7 psi per 10 degrees on a tire set at 35 psi. That is why the TPMS light comes on the first truly cold morning: nothing leaked, the air simply contracted.

  • A 40-degree drop from a mild afternoon to a hard freeze takes about 2.8 psi out of a tire set at 35 psi, from temperature alone.
  • Set pressure cold, before driving, because a rolling tire heats up and reads high.
  • Check monthly through winter rather than once in the fall; each cold snap moves the number again.
  • Running low on pavement for snow backfires: it widens the footprint, the opposite of the ground pressure you want.
  • Airing down for deep snow off pavement is a trail move. Air back up before the highway.

The starting number comes from the placard on the driver's door jamb, adjusted for load with the tire maker's load-and-inflation table. The calculator corrects a cold pressure for a temperature swing; it cannot tell you what pressure to start from.

Which head-to-head comparisons cover winter tires?

If your shortlist is down to two models, these comparisons put them side by side on all 10 axes. They are ordered by snow score, highest first, so the winter-relevant matchups lead.

How should you pick a winter tire for your Tacoma?

  1. Decide whether ice is part of your winter. If it is, plan on a dedicated winter set; if it is snow and slush on maintained roads, a 3PMSF all-terrain is the better value.
  2. Settle the size before the model. Your factory size, or a smaller winter wheel that clears your brakes, eliminates most of the catalog before you compare treads.
  3. Filter to 3PMSF in that exact size code, since the mark can vary within a model line.
  4. Rank what is left on the other axes: wet grip for slush, then tread life and comfort for the rest of the year.
  5. Set pressure from the door placard once mounted, and correct it at the first cold snap.

Frequently asked questions

Keep going

Sources

Compare your exact sizes

Run any size in this guide through the Tacoma tire size calculator to see diameter, width, speedometer error, effective gearing, and highway RPM before you buy.